24 September 2008

Ranking graduate departments

On Some Random Webpage Full Of Spam, I came across what purports to be US News' 2009 ranking of graduate programs in mathematics. (I feel bad about linking to this, because it just helps the spammers, but I'm doing it anyway.)

If I remember correctly, this ranking is produced by surveying people in mathematics departments at various schools and asking them to rank other institutions. That's it.

It seems to me that a more sensible way of ranking mathematics departments would be to start with the assumption that a better department is, by definition, one which has its students get hired by better departments. This could work, at least to do the high end of the ranking, because the departments doing the hiring are often the same departments that have graduate students; eventually I expect the process I'm alluding to would converge on a ranking. I'm not sure what you'd do to deal with ranking "lesser" programs where many students are not hired by departments which themselves have doctoral programs. This just aggregates what people think about reputation, but in a way that's more principled than just asking some shadowy panel thinks.

Of course, in the end these sorts of rankings are not particularly valuable, so I don't want to pursue this any further.

(Disclaimer: my memory of how these rankings work comes from standing in a bookstore four years ago and copying down that year's rankings on a scrap of paper. I think the statue of limitations has passed on that, so I'll admit to it.)

6 comments:

Nathan said...

Your ranking idea sounds a bit like PageRank. Now when does the phone come out?

unapologetic said...

Damn, Nathan beat me to it. A hire is a link to each institution in that professor's CV.

Boris said...

Why don't you link to the official US News and World Report math grad ranking?

Billlion said...

In the UK we have some slightly crazy newspaper league tables and the one for maths are often a bit strange. Pretty much everyone in mathematics in the UK agrees that Cambridge Oxford Warwick and Imperial "COWI" are the top four, but its anybody's guess who is next.

I had a go at compiling an objective list comparing uk math departments based on some published figures. But I also had the idea like you of a kind of "page rank" for the flow of people between departmnets, but I was thinking of tenured academics voting with their feet. If only that data was available easily. of course to some extent the institute codes in mathscinet can be used to track people moving between departments.

Julian said...

You said "I feel bad about linking to this, because it just helps the spammers"

Check out NoFollow as a simple solution.

Anonymous said...

Greetings girl. I am only I start to study masters degree program.
I have visited a site http://program.v3host.be/?cat=672.
Much to our regret I have very little found out about it.
You can probably tell to me a good site about masters degree programs.
I will be very glad.
Thansk